Tuesday 3 October 2006

Quotes regarding deafness

Sometimes quotes, being used in signatures of posts on messageboards, can give a beautiful insight in the world of the deaf. Positive and negative.

"Tell the mothers I said, "Don't try to change your child; you are the adult, you bear the burden of change" "
- Harlan Lane
"

This one is about parents that find out that the child is deaf. It was first used in a time where CI's were not common yet and/or results were lower compared to today. The argument is in my opinion true in case the child remains deaf. In that case I do feel it is important that the parent makes sure that communication with the child is established. In the case of a deaf child, this is sign language. Sign would be th natural choice, and parents will need to adapt and learn this means of communication.
The quote is sometimes used to support the feelings of many Deaf people that feel that the child is the one that has to make the choice.
I feel that it is the parent who has that responsibility. Making the choice that the child has to make the choice lay's down another starting position for the deaf child.
To me, the quote is more correct when it is transformed to this:

"Tell the parents I said, "Help your child; you are the adult, you bear the burden of responsibility to give the child all the possibilities life can give" "

I found another one related to the Harlan Lane quote by CiPop on DeafNotes, who said:

"Parents, continue acting in the best interests of your children for Harlan Lane has been proven wrong!" - CiPop

And CiPop has good right to say that. His daughter has had CI for the last 17 years. He has been a pioneer far more than we ever will be..
And I can say that Lotte has also proven Harlan Lane wrong.
(Proven wrong based on the book "Mask of Benevolence" by Harlan Lane - 1993 (The CI-part of the book is really out of date and really not valid any more.) )


Other quotes regarding deafnes, picked from the internet:

"What matters deafness of the ear, when the mind hears. The one true deafness- the incurable deafness- is that of the mind."
- Victor Hugo

"One and the same thing can at the same time be good, bad, and indifferent, e.g., music is good to the melancholy, bad to those who mourn, and neither good nor bad to the deaf."
- Baruch Spinoza

"But people who think they can project themselves into deafness are mistaken because you can't.
And I'm not talking about imagining what a deaf person's whole life is like. I even mean just realizing what it is like for an instant."

- Richard Masur


No comments:

(Some) Milestones

  • 2013-08: Grade 6
  • 2012-08: Grade 5
  • 2011-08: Grade 4
  • 2011-03: BTE's on the ear
  • 2010-08: Grade 3
  • 2009-08: Grade 2
  • 2008-08: Mainstream School (6y. old)
  • 2006-10: All-hearing Kindergarten (4y. old)
  • 2004-11-22: CI activated (27 m. old)
  • 2004-10-04: Bi-lateral CI (26 m. old)
  • 2003-08: Deaf/HOH/CI Pre-school/"DEAF" Kindergarten (12m. old)
  • 2003-07: HA's fitted (11 m. old)
  • 2003-06: Diagnosed deaf. Start sign-language (10m. old)
  • 2002-11: Suspicion loss of hearing (4 m. old)
  • 2002-08: Born - A fierce LION
--- Google Analytics